The natural impulse is to repeat, in this new form, the existing shows from older media. That is called "the law of implementation": we use the new to do the old, even if it doesn't need doing at all.
βAt the Flip Pointββ (1975), typescript, p 5
The βLaw of Implementationβ is that the newest awareness must be processed by the established procedures. [Italicized in the book]
Take Today with Barrington Nevitt, 1973, p 236
For heaven knows how long, people have encountered each new technology by translating it back into the old familiar one. You know all the types of examples of that. The first motor cars were made with buggy whip holders. And the new automation computer devices are being made as if they were card catalogues. This strange habit of looking backward when moving forward is one that perhaps won't quite bear up, isn't quite consistent with jet speeds and electronic speeds.
βThe Medium Is the Massageβ (1966), in Understanding Me (2003), p 86
The old reveals the newβ¦ Old movies advertise the world of difference in the TV medium, i.e., few [old movies] will βworkβ on TV.
Early tetrad for βLaw of Implementation,β from first widely distributed early draft, Laws of the Media with Eric McLuhan (1975), p 281
The law of implementation is always to use the new thing for the old purpose, while ignoring that the new thing tends to destroy the old purposes. I have discovered over the years that the effects of innovation are always subliminal, and because people resent having this pointed out, feeling that you are invading their privacy by so doing.
Letter to Pierre Elliott Trudeau, March 26, 1974 in Letters of Marshall McLuhan (1987) p 494
[T]he computer is being set to do all the old jobs, nothing new. It is like buggy-whip holders in the first motor car.
βInformation Hunt Looms Bigβ (1967), p 6
For a century the book, the printed book, pretended to be a cheap manuscript.
The Electr Revol in N. Amer, 1959, p 8
For a decade or more radio executives refused to broadcast because it was alien to the nature of "wire-less" to diffuse. The radio hams forced the hand of executives to become broadcasters.
βThe Electronic Revolution in North Americaβ (1958), p 8 Page does not match the 58 txt,not found in 59 Laws of implementation+ innovation
We use the new to do the old, even if it doesn't need doing at all. (The Law of Implementation)
βAt the Flip Pointββ (1975), typescript, p 5
History need never be oriented to the past. But to-day when we are again trying to make the new media do the old jobs we also have an orientation to the past which ensures the destruction of all achieved values, like recording on recorded tape.
Letter to David Riesman (1960), in Letters of Marshall McLuhan (1987), p 261
We seem stuck with the age-old habit of using new means for old purposes instead of discovering what are the new goals contained in the new means.
From ClichΓ© to Archetype with Wilfred Watson, 1970, p 202
Why do people assume that there's an absolute, static fixed value inherent in some pre existing situation, while they spend all their time and energy creating new situations which will surely liquidate the pre-existing one?
Letter to Claude Bissell (Dec. 14, 1960), in Letters of Marshall McLuhan (1987), p 275
The Law of Implementation is always to use the new thing for the old purpose, while ignoring that the new thing tends to destroy the old purposes. I have discovered over the years that the effects of innovation are always subliminal, and people resent having this pointed out, feeling that you are invading their privacy in so doing.
Letter to Pierre Elliott Trudeau (1974), in Letters of Marshall McLuhan (1987), p 494
Just as television programmers still work with the movie techniques... you find that the planners of the spaceship earth continue to work with metropolitan concepts.
βThe global theatreβ, in Ekistics 190 (Sept 1971), p 181
Like the physicists, Heidegger is trying to do the new thing in the old way: he has retrieved percepts as a tool for exploring the occult (hidden) area, but the manner is still abstract (visual)
Laws of Media: The New Science with Eric McLuhan, (1988), p 63
An almost inevitable thing is whenever a new service is available you do the old thing with the new thing. And so it doesn't matter what the new thing is, you try to do the old thing with it.
βIt Will Probably End the Motor Carβ, interview. Cinema Canada. 1976, p 27
In the same way, the computer is not a new mechanical gadget for pepping up the old mechanical environment. The computer is not mechanical at all. Electric circuitry is an organic thing, an extension of our nervous system. Our natural impulse is to ignore the environmental aspects and to try to fit it into the old situation in the style of "horseless carriage" and "wireless." But our natural response is quite helpless and irrelevant, as the history of technology testifies.
βThe Emperorβs Old Clothesβ (1966), in McLuhan Unbound (2005), p 9